they have claim to the islands because they fucking live there dude
because i’m sensing a “you’re just a british nationalist” coming in the immediate future, i’ll just make my position clear
if the islanders decided that they would rather be argentinian, i would wholeheartedly support argentina’s claim to the islands
This. People first. Peoples right to self determination and democracy from top to bottom in society is paramount. As communists, that principle is absolute.
You’re acting like the Argentinian government is gonna massacre them the second power is transferred. Probably nothing would change but Argentina would get the profit from oil and tourism.
Like Argentinians are not on average wealthy people. The British people living on those islands probably have it way better than most of the people in Argentina. It’s kind of gross.
Idealist nonsense, says the person who wants to divide up all natural resources equally into amorphous national state boundaries regardless of the wishes of the people who live there, until all national states have equal populations, areas, and access to natural wealth?
You’re literally just spewing more idealist nonsense. You know that countries are a thing that still exist right? Either Argentina gets to benefit from the islands, or Britain (lmao) does. You’re saying the British should benefit because they colonized some islands hundreds of years ago and there’s a couple thousand people there. If there was 1 person living in the Falklands, would that justify oil and gas drilling and a British military outpost?
resource extraction near some town? And they’re not like colnized oppressed people they’re just some probably comfortable British people. They’re not in some anti-colonial struggle give me a break.
There’s a point where it tips from “just some people living on an island” and becomes “Britain maintaining an imperial outpost for resource extraction”.
they have claim to the islands because they fucking live there dude
because i’m sensing a “you’re just a british nationalist” coming in the immediate future, i’ll just make my position clear
if the islanders decided that they would rather be argentinian, i would wholeheartedly support argentina’s claim to the islands
This. People first. Peoples right to self determination and democracy from top to bottom in society is paramount. As communists, that principle is absolute.
You’re acting like the Argentinian government is gonna massacre them the second power is transferred. Probably nothing would change but Argentina would get the profit from oil and tourism.
Like Argentinians are not on average wealthy people. The British people living on those islands probably have it way better than most of the people in Argentina. It’s kind of gross.
Humans don’t exist to create profit for the Argentinian government.
deleted by creator
Yeah it’s so inconvenient for these people to exist.
deleted by creator
Settler 👌 Settler-colonial 👎💀
deleted by creator
You’re repeating rhetoric without considering context.
lol idealist nonsense. Argentinians would see more wealth from owning the islands than they do now.
Idealist nonsense, says the person who wants to divide up all natural resources equally into amorphous national state boundaries regardless of the wishes of the people who live there, until all national states have equal populations, areas, and access to natural wealth?
You’re literally just spewing more idealist nonsense. You know that countries are a thing that still exist right? Either Argentina gets to benefit from the islands, or Britain (lmao) does. You’re saying the British should benefit because they colonized some islands hundreds of years ago and there’s a couple thousand people there. If there was 1 person living in the Falklands, would that justify oil and gas drilling and a British military outpost?
yes, because people matter more than realpolitik shit
Apparently poor Argentinians who could benefit from social program funding don’t matter, but white British people living in a colonial outpost do.
deleted by creator
Yeah those occupying powers like the British Empire. You’re gonna act like Alberto Fernandez is gonna massacre some people living on an island lol.
deleted by creator
resource extraction near some town? And they’re not like colnized oppressed people they’re just some probably comfortable British people. They’re not in some anti-colonial struggle give me a break.
deleted by creator
There’s a point where it tips from “just some people living on an island” and becomes “Britain maintaining an imperial outpost for resource extraction”.
So you’re saying that sometimes it’s ok to conquer people who have done nothing but exist, as a treat.
Again you’re acting like a transfer of ownership from THE BRITISH GOVERNMENT to Argentina is “conquering” lmao.
How you gonna transfer ownership if the people living there don’t want to transfer ownership?
edit: wait we’ve seen this one before, let’s do some greatest hits and get hundreds of people killed again.
Literally Richard Spencer “peaceful relocation” bullshit at this point.
Who said they had to relocate?
No one, full support for just killing Argentinian occupation soldiers until they go home.